Late last night multiple media outlets announced that Indy Eleven’s Owner Ersal Ozdemir would personally hand in an application to the Front Office of Major League Soccer in New York City on Tuesday which led to mixed reviews from Supporters through out the Club. Interesting as it is this is about 1 year after outside investors spread interest in bringing a Major League Soccer franchise to Indianapolis on the grounds of the former Indianapolis International Airport grounds in 2016 but it failed in a vote last year. Now a year later Indy Eleven joins 12 other clubs wanting to invest in becoming one of the 4 expansion sides in 2020. What are some Pros and Cons of this move?
- Stadium Talks in Downtown Indy will be reconsidered with a closer look:
In 2015 Indy Eleven brought up the idea of building a multipurpose stadium in Downtown Indy with the “Stadium for Indiana” Campaign with the notion of building a permanent home for Indy Eleven for the city along with opportunities for Concert Space, High School Soccer Games, High School Football Games, and much more. It managed to pass through the General Assembly but the bill died once it hit the Indiana Senate. Many of the complications with the Stadium plan was the fact that many Hoosiers are not for publicly paying for another sports venue after picking up the bill for the Original Hoosier Dome, Bankers Life Fieldhouse, and most recently Lucas Oil Stadium. Since 2015 Indy Eleven and Peter Wilt parted ways so Wilt could begin work on the Chicago NASL Project and along with this Jeff Belskus the former CEO of the Indianapolis Motor Speedway was named the President of Indy Eleven in 2016. During last night’s news Sports Illustrated said that Ozdemir and Belskus have made moves to pay for the Stadium with Club related profit based off of money spent within the Club. Citing that this may end the political bind that will lead to a clear pathway for Indy Eleven to build a new Stadium. Of course. Time will tell.
Here is a link to Indy Eleven’s 2015 Stadium Campaign
2. The Future of the North American Soccer League:
It hasn’t even been a month since Sunil Gulati made the move to make the NASL and United Soccer League have co-ownership of the 2nd division on the American Pyramid. Given the NASL is said to expand to 11 teams by the Fall Season and other NASL franchises applying for MLS Expansion as well could hurt the NASL very badly. Another issue that many Indianapolis Citizens had with the Stadium bid was also the future of the North American Soccer League saying things such as the NASL doesn’t have the backing to support Soccer Specific Stadiums in the League. It’s solely a conflict of interest. North Carolina FC (originally The Carolina Railhawks) joined into the MLS bid early than the Eleven did but they also took a role of leadership being one of the key voices to have the NASL survive into 2017. The NASL has made good moves since the announcement was made by letting go of former commissioner Bill Peterson and having the New York Cosmos sold to have the league be at 8 teams in the Spring Season.
3. Other Markets looking at MLS Expansion:
Keep in mind there are 4 spots for 2020 but also there is a chance at another round of expansion in 2024.
Cities in the Mix: Charlotte, Cincinnati, Detroit, Nashville, Raleigh, Sacramento, St. Louis, San Antonio, San Diego and Tampa Bay, and Phoenix have all come forward to be interested in MLS Expansion.
Cities most likely to get Expansion based off their current state outside of Indianapolis:
Cincinnati:
FC Cincinnati has become a success story in 2016 when the Club managed to sell out the University of Cincinnati’s Football Stadium for FC Cincinnati and the Club has been very open about expanding to Major League Soccer and has had Don Garber visit the Club in its inaugural season.
Sacramento:
The Sacramento Republic Football Club are a crown jewel of the Independent Clubs in the United Soccer League that have been around for a good amount of time that have an average attendance of around 11,000 in the last 3 seasons. They have also been in the talks of a 4th California MLS Franchise for quite sometime.
St. Louis:
St. Louis has also been very open to bringing MLS to STL. There is also an active campaign to bring a soccer specific stadium to the City. St. Louis FC has an average attendance of around 6,000 however the City has a rich soccer history that can bring up better chances and opportunities to build up the fanbase. Unfortunately St. Louis did lose it’s NFL Franchise at the end of the 2015 Season when the Rams decided to return to Los Angeles which could make it harder for STLFC to make a solid push.
San Diego:
We are really pushing it with this one solely for the fact that San Diego’s Soccer following is mostly in it’s Mexican sister city Tijuana with Club Tijuana in Liga MX. However San Diego has had an NASL Club in the past and has a lot of interest from Don Garber to put a club on the map there to compete with the Liga MX Franchise.
For more information and indepth analysis on Soccer Expansion in North America we do recommend looking into Midfield Press’ on going coverage of the situation at all levels of the pyramid. You can be find this by clicking Here.
Contributor’s Thoughts:
While I do believe that Major League Soccer is the best direction for the longterm survival of the Indy Eleven I do believe that the only way a soccer specific stadium to come to Indianapolis is through private funding given our city is fitting the bill for many other venues in the past. Indy Eleven has made a great Soccer Culture in Indianapolis that has a lot of room to grow as the club continues to get bigger. An MLS spot could mean many more opportunities for future trophies for the Club and more international recognition. However, Indy Eleven is one of the few NASL Success Stories left along with NCFC, the reboot New York Cosmos and Minnesota (who are now in MLS) There is a lot of work to be done however the interest has always been here to bring a third major sports franchise to the city.